ورقة عمل لمقارنة عروض أسعار مولدات الديزل لمشتري المشاريع
Two offers arrive in procurement with the same kW figure. One has a control cabinet in the package price; the other refers to a cabinet by the installation contractor. Put the totals side by side without resolving that line and the comparison starts with unlike scopes.
Use a buyer-owned worksheet to expose those differences before ranking offers. One row per requirement, one column per bidder and a source reference for each entry is usually enough to show what can be compared and what still needs an answer.
This article focuses on that comparison task. It does not select the generator capacity, establish project compliance or replace the purchase agreement. Those decisions need their own approved inputs.

Freeze the enquiry before comparing prices
Freeze the enquiry reference first. Put the equipment schedule, duty, electrical data, site conditions and scope notes in a register with revision and issue date. A file called “latest” in an email can mean different things to different bidders.
Keep an enquiry change log. When a revised requirement goes out, record which bidders received it and which offers they updated. Until every price is tied to the same requirement baseline, leave the ranking provisional.
Our overview of custom generator configuration options explains why the package can extend beyond the generating set itself. In the worksheet, name the actual requested configuration rather than treating customization as a single included item.
The buyer’s schedule should define the rows. Supplier quotations define the columns. This small choice matters: using one bidder’s quotation as the worksheet template can turn that bidder’s exclusions into the assumed scope. Keep options beneath, rather than inside, the base offer.
Build a scope row for every deliverable
Break “generator package” into things the project will receive or pay for. A battery may be included while its charger is optional; drawings may be included while a witnessed test is not. Record those separately so one inclusive line does not hide a split.
Use the same status vocabulary for every bid: included, excluded, optional, unclear. If the quotation says nothing about an item, leave it unclear. Silence is a question for the bidder, not a zero-cost allowance for the comparison.
|
Worksheet field |
What the buyer should enter |
Supporting record |
|
Requirement |
Exact item and requested boundary |
Enquiry clause or drawing |
|
Offered scope |
Supplier description and configuration |
Quotation page or schedule |
|
Status |
Included, excluded, optional or unclear |
Written supplier statement |
|
Difference |
What changes the project purchase |
Clarification reference |
|
Resolution |
Agreed treatment and responsible party |
Revised offer or agreement |
For loose items, record quantities and whether they ship fitted or separately packed. For documents, identify the required format, language and approval stage. A promise to provide manuals does not establish whether project-specific drawings are also included.
Keep site work separate from equipment supply. Receiving, unloading, installation, cabling and commissioning may involve different parties. The comparison should expose those boundaries without assuming a standard arrangement applies to every project.
Keep technical deviations visible
Put a deviation next to the requirement it changes. In adjacent cells, copy the requested condition, the offered condition and the supplier’s explanation. The responsible engineer can then decide the technical disposition before procurement treats the lower number as an equivalent offer.
One “compliant” checkbox for a whole quotation can bury an exception in a footnote or a different controller in an attachment. Review the quotation, exclusions, schedules and referenced data sheets together.
Where support is part of the comparison, use our معلومات الخدمة as an introduction to the discussion. Confirm the actual project scope in writing, including who performs the work, where it takes place and which costs are included. A general service page is not a project service commitment.
Keep alternatives separate from the base offer. If an enclosure, controller or test arrangement changes, give the alternative its own identifier. Otherwise the comparison may combine the price of the base offer with features available only in the alternative.
Do not assign invented cost allowances to unresolved technical differences. Ask for an actual clarification or keep the commercial impact open. A spreadsheet can look complete while still depending on assumptions that no supplier has accepted.
Compare commercial terms on the same basis
Price alone rarely gives a comparable total. Capture currency, validity, payment events and delivery basis. Put freight, taxes and local work in separate lines until their treatment is known. If a delivery abbreviation affects risk or cost, refer it to the contract team instead of guessing from the shorthand.
Write the event that starts the lead-time clock beside the number of weeks. One supplier may count from order; another may count from approved drawings. The durations only line up after their starting events do.
Read warranty wording as supplied for the order. Capture what equipment it covers, when it starts, any time or operating-hour limit, exclusions and claim process. A general web page cannot fill a term missing from a particular quotation.
If the buyer uses a common currency for evaluation, record the conversion date and rate source. Keep the original quoted values visible. Separate that accounting conversion from any supplier commitment to hold a price in another currency.
Place unresolved taxes, freight or local work in an open-cost register. The worksheet should show that the evaluated total is incomplete until those items are resolved. Precision in the displayed total does not make an uncertain cost certain.
Control revisions through the award decision

Preserve each offer revision. Mark the active version, the reason for the change and the rows it affects. If a figure is replaced, keep the earlier value and its source linked in the worksheet’s revision history.
When clarifying an offer with أولينغن, put the quotation ID and configuration on each question. That makes it clear whether the response applies to this enquiry or an earlier, similar discussion.
Before recommending an award, check that the technical recommendation and the commercial comparison refer to the same revision. A price update issued after engineering review may also change scope. The buyer needs to know whether it is a price-only revision or a new technical offer.
Maintain an assumptions column until the award package is settled. Every remaining assumption should have an owner and a proposed resolution. If an assumption becomes an agreed term, move it into the relevant purchase document and retain its history.
Someone who missed the clarification calls should still be able to trace the recommendation: selected offer, unresolved rows, decision owner and source documents. If they must reconstruct an email chain, the comparison is not ready to support an award.
Send a clarification package that can be answered
Turn the open rows into a numbered clarification list. Cite the requirement and quotation line, then ask one question. “Does line 4 include two chargers?” can be answered; “please confirm the full scope” invites another round of ambiguity.
Request the effect of each answer on scope, price and timing where relevant. Keep the supplier’s response beside the original question. If the answer changes the offer, obtain a revised document or another written record accepted by the purchasing team.
As a worksheet example, suppose one offer lists an enclosure separately while another includes an enclosure in the package price. Keep both original entries, then ask whether the proposed arrangements meet the same enquiry requirement. Do not simply add the optional price and call the offers equivalent; the configurations still need technical comparison. This example illustrates the review method, not a finding about any supplier’s actual offer.
When ready, تواصل مع فريقنا with the enquiry revision, quotation reference and unresolved worksheet rows. That package gives the discussion a defined starting point and helps keep the eventual purchase aligned with the configuration the project actually reviewed.








